Seven days on one Bill Monroe song: where it came from, the chop under it, the three chords it runs on, and the fiddle inside the mandolin.
One day at a time. Do today's card, then close the page.
This week is paper. Nothing on it listens. The lessons, and the checks on your playing, are in the app.
Uncle Pen
Big idea: a song is a machine, and by Sunday the ear can take it apart.
Uncle Pen is Bill Monroe's own song, written and recorded in 1950, and it is still under copyright, so there is no notation on this page, no tablature and no chord chart. The song is learned off the record by ear, which is what this week asks for anyway.
The story
Bill Monroe was born in Rosine, Kentucky, in 1911. After his parents died, he lived with his mother's brother, James Pendleton Vandiver, a fiddler everybody called Uncle Pen. Monroe accompanied him at dances. Years later he wrote Uncle Pen about the man and about the musical world that helped form him.
This week asks more than whether the notes are right. By Sunday you should hear why the song sounds the way it does.
The weekly arc
Mondaystory and listening
Tuesdaychop and pulse
Wednesdaythe I-IV-V map
Thursdaymelody by ear
Fridaybluegrass phrasing
Saturdayfiddle influence
Sundayintegration
Do one day at a time. Write the questions, the recordings and the discoveries down as they come up: the box at the foot of this page is for them.
The chop
Beats 2 and 4 are only the address. Where the chop lands, a little early, a little late, or right in the pocket, is what creates the feel.
I, IV, V
I is home. IV steps away. V creates the strongest demand to return.
Playing by ear
Find one note, then the next. Four notes discovered teach more than forty copied.
Seven cards on paper, with room to write. Your ticks and your answers come out with it.
Start with the man, then the pulse
Monday + Tuesday
Day 1 | about 25 minutes
Who was Uncle Pen?
Focus: meet the human story before touching the instrument.
What to notice: Bill Monroe was born in Rosine, Kentucky, in 1911. After his parents died, the teenage Monroe lived with his mother's brother, James Pendleton Vandiver, the fiddler everybody called Uncle Pen. Vandiver played dances, and Monroe accompanied him. Before he became the Father of Bluegrass, Monroe learned what music could do by standing beside an older Kentucky fiddler.
Uncle PenBill Monroe and His Blue Grass Boys, 1950, mandolin and vocalThe original, cut for Decca. This is the record the whole week works from, so start here and keep coming back to it. The link is a search: the master is on a label, and the copies on video sites come and go.Listenhttps://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=Bill+Monroe+and+His+Blue+Grass+Boys+Uncle+Pen+1950+Decca
Uncle PenRicky Skaggs, 1984, mandolin and vocalThe same song taken to country radio thirty four years later, faster and brighter, with the fiddle further forward. Worth hearing second, once Monroe's version is in your ear, because the difference between the two is mostly the thing Friday is about. The link is a search.Listenhttps://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=Ricky+Skaggs+Uncle+Pen+1984
Day 2 | 20 to 30 minutes
Find the heartbeat
Focus: build the rhythmic skeleton before learning any melody.
What to notice: The mandolin chop does almost the job a snare drum does in a band that has no drums. A tiny shift in timing can make the whole groove drag, push, or sit comfortably.
Jam along with a bass and a guitarA recorded bass and guitar that play any chart on this site at the speed you set, so 2 and 4 have somewhere to land once the song is off. Pick a chart in A, the key of Monroe's record, leave the melody alone, and chop.mandolintrainer.com/jam/
Map the harmony, then hunt the melody
Wednesday + Thursday
Day 3 | about 30 minutes
Draw the chord map
Focus: hear what a chord is doing instead of memorizing which letter it is.
What to notice: I is home. IV moves away without demanding to be resolved straight away. V creates stronger tension, the feeling that it needs to return to I.
The chord chartEvery shape on one page, with a grid for each. Today only needs three of them.mandolintrainer.com/chords/
An empty chart in A, for you to fill inThe Jam Builder, opened in A with a verse and a chorus laid out, eight bars each and every bar blank. Tap in the chords you heard, then play it back with the band.mandolintrainer.com/app/#jam?c=1~A~Week%201%20changes~Verse.1.-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-~Chorus.1.-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-%7C-
Day 4 | 30 to 40 minutes
Melody detective
Focus: use your ears first, and bring in notation only after you have hunted for the phrase.
Bach transfer: this is the bridge to the week's Bach track. In the Bourrée, a melody can imply the harmony. In Uncle Pen, a melody can interact with it. The musical language differs, but the listening skill is the same.
Make it speak, and borrow from the fiddle
Friday + Saturday
Day 5 | about 30 minutes
Make it sound like bluegrass
Focus: turn correct pitches into phrasing with direction and personality.
What to notice: The notes do not fully define a style. Accent, timing, space, attack, and the direction of the passing notes are what make the line begin to speak.
Day 6 | 30 to 40 minutes
Meet the fiddler inside the mandolin player
Focus: ask a picked instrument to borrow the continuity and color of a fiddle.
What to notice: A fiddle can sustain, slide, drone, and connect notes without being asked. The mandolin has to create those impressions through picking, slurs, open strings, double stops, timing, and touch.
Glory In the Meeting HouseLuther Strong, 1937, fiddleFree to hear. Alan and Elizabeth Lomax recorded Strong at Hazard, in Perry County, Kentucky, in October 1937, when Monroe was twenty six. Listen for how much of the tune is played on two strings at once, and how much of it sits on a drone.Listenhttps://archive.org/details/afc1937001_1536A2
Bonaparte's RetreatWilliam Hamilton Stepp, 1937, fiddleFree to hear, from the same Kentucky trip: Stepp was recorded at Salyersville, in Magoffin County, later that month. A slower one, and the clearest lesson in sustain a mandolin player can get, because every place the bow holds a note is a place the pick has to invent something.Listenhttps://archive.org/details/afc1937001_1568A2
Hear the whole machine at once
Sunday
Day 7 | 30 to 40 minutes
Put the machine together
Focus: integrate story, rhythm, harmony, melody, and phrasing. Learn nothing new today.
What to notice: Monroe grew up hearing a fiddler make an instrument talk, and then built one of the most distinctive mandolin voices in American music. The larger question is how much of his language came from making a picked instrument behave like the fiddle music he knew.
Chop and play the whole song with the bandThe finished chart: the week's changes in A, verse and chorus, looping under a recorded bass and guitar at whatever speed you set. Compare it with the one you built on Wednesday before you play.mandolintrainer.com/app/#jam?c=1~A~Week%201%20changes~Verse.1.A%7CA%7CA%7CE%20A%7CA%7CA%7CA%7CE%20A~Chorus.1.D%7CA%7CA%7CE%20A%7CA%7CA%7CA%7CE%20A&go=play
Sunday checkpoint
I can explain who Uncle Pen was.
I can define I, IV, and V in this song.
I can hear tension and resolution.
I can chop through the changes.
I can play a substantial part of the melody by ear.
I can name at least one melody note as a root, a third, or a fifth.
The song does not need to be performance-ready. Understanding it is part of learning it.
Questions and discoveries
Keep the pace: one song a week, a day at a time. The week ends on Sunday and not before.